Sicilian pies often get overlooked or don't get the praise they deserve. I love a good Sicilian square slice when done to perfection and there are plenty of places in the 5 boroughs that not only do them well, but have become really adventurous. I felt inclined to share my top 3 Sicilian slices in NYC as I respect anyone searching for a good one. From the sweet and spicy embrace of hot honey to the unadulterated simplicity of a classic plain slice, and the creative explosion of flavors, each pizzeria mentioned below offers a unique experience that will leave you craving for more.
Hands down one of my favorite slices of pizza in NYC; the Hotboii. Picture this: a golden square of Sicilian goodness adorned with pepperoni cups, jalapenos slices that offer a subtle kick, and a drizzle of hot honey where each bite has the perfect balance of sweet and spicy. Highly recommend.
Here you can find more adventurous Sicilian slices or culinary innovation – whichever you would like to call it. If you want to be adventurous and try out some different toppings this is your place! I had a pesto, pepperoni, hot honey slice along with a vodka sauce slice with pepperoni as well. Multiple thumbs up!
This spot proves that sometimes simplicity is the ultimate sophistication. Their plain Sicilian slice is a testament to the artistry of pizza making – a fluffy yet perfectly crisp crust, a rich layer of tomato sauce, and a generous dusting of high quality cheese. It’s pizza in its purest form, allowing the ingredients to shine with every delightful bite.
Looking for more culinary inspiration in NYC, check out this link!